The breeding populations of the black-headed gull (Larus ridibundus) a
nd the herring gull (Larus argentatus) on the Wadden Sea island of Sch
arhorn (Germany) increased until 1985 to about 320 and 280 breeding pa
irs, respectively. The aim of our study was to investigate whether the
breeding success of the common tern (Sterna hirundo) was affected by
chick removal due to gull predation. Attacks by flying gulls started s
hortly after the first tern chicks hatched. More than 360 successful c
ases of tern chick removal by black-headed gulls and about 770 cases b
y herring gulls were observed. For the herring but not for the black-h
eaded gull, time of day had an effect on the rate of successful chick
removals. No significant effect of the tidal stage was discernible. Re
gardless of time of day and stage of tide, chick removal by black-head
ed and herring gulls was positively correlated with wind velocities. D
uring stormy days the smaller terns were not able to attack intruding
gulls successfully. Gull attacks affect the breeding success of terns
directly (by chick predation) and presumably indirectly (by enhancing
chick mortality due to underweight caused by frequent interruptions of
the breeding process). As gull attacks are largely restricted to stor
my days, we conclude that terns do not suffer from gull attacks during
breeding seasons with good weather conditions. We recommend to refrai
n from regulating gull stocks in the breeding colonies, and focus inst
ead on other, more effective management procedures such as closure of
waste disposals and reducing the by-catch of fisheries.