E. Fernandez et al., RETROPERITONEAL IMAGING WITH 3RD AND 4TH GENERATION COMPUTED AXIAL-TOMOGRAPHY IN CLINICAL STAGE-I NONSEMINOMATOUS GERM-CELL TUMORS, Urology, 44(4), 1994, pp. 548-552
Objectives. To examine the accuracy rate of abdominal staging using th
ird and fourth generation computed tomography (CT) scanning in clinica
l Stage I testicular nonseminoma patients. Methods. Between January 19
85 and August 1993, 57 patients presented to our center with clinical
Stage I testicular nonseminoma. Retroperitoneal computed tomographic s
taging studies were interpreted to be normal preoperatively in the ent
ire group. In addition, tumor marker values were normal or returned to
normal postorchiectomy within the appropriate half-life intervals. Al
l patients were subjected to radical or modified retroperitoneal lymph
node dissection (19% and 72%, respectively). Original abdominal CT sc
ans (preretroperitoneal lymph node dissection) were available for blin
ded retrospective re-review in 16 cases (7 pathologic Stage II, 9 path
ologic Stage I). Results. Nineteen of 57 (33%) patients were upstaged
at surgery including 6 patients (11%) who demonstrated II B volume dis
ease. Third and fourth generation CT scanning of the retroperitoneum y
ielded a 66% accuracy rate in this population. Six out of 7 pathologic
Stage II pre-lymph node dissection abdominal CT scans that were avail
able for blinded re-review revealed nonpathologic nodes by size criter
ia in the primary landing zone for the corresponding original tumor. C
onclusions. Our data suggests that for clinical Stage I nonseminoma in
the 1985 to 1993 era, undue reliance was placed on a less than ideal
staging test. The 33% false-negative rate reported showed no improveme
nt over earlier reports and reaffirms concern for relying solely on th
ird or fourth generation CT imaging of the retroperitoneum in the stag
ing of clinical Stage I nonseminomatous germ cell tumor (NSGCT) patien
ts. The presence of any number of lymph nodes in the expected primary
landing zone, regardless of size, should raise serious suspicion for o
ccult nodal disease.