HEALTH-CARE REFORM - A STUDY IN MORAL MALFEASANCE

Authors
Citation
Ht. Engelhardt, HEALTH-CARE REFORM - A STUDY IN MORAL MALFEASANCE, The Journal of medicine and philosophy, 19(5), 1994, pp. 501-516
Citations number
22
Categorie Soggetti
Philosophy,"Social Issues
ISSN journal
03605310
Volume
19
Issue
5
Year of publication
1994
Pages
501 - 516
Database
ISI
SICI code
0360-5310(1994)19:5<501:HR-ASI>2.0.ZU;2-7
Abstract
Instead of benefitting from open meetings and public discussions, the Clintons drafted their health care plan in private and asked that it b e accepted in haste. They advance an ideology that claims we can recei ve the best care for all without any increase in cost or rationing, an d then they use ''ethicists'' to justify this ideology through a suppo sedly common morality. However, there is no such common morality. In t he context of American pluralism, one must look to the actual consent of the governed and recognize the limits on state authority. The resul t will be a two tiered system of health care, with a basic tier focusi ng on cost-effective care for the poor that eliminates suffering rathe r than equalizing inputs, and a space for collateral private insurance .