Background. Although liver transplantation offers definitive treatment
for portal hypertension with end-stage liver failure, surgical portos
ystemic shunts avoid the risks of transplantation and immunosuppressiv
e therapy, and transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) cr
eates a portosystemic shunt with minimal operative risk. The appropria
te applications of these modalities are discussed. Methods. All adults
undergoing primary liver transplantation alone (PLT, n = 265), PLT af
ter TIPS (n = 34), PLT after surgical shunts (n = 12), surgical shunt
alone (n = 13), TIPS alone (n = 35), or surgical shunt after PLT (n =
5) served as the basis of this study. Results. In contrast to surgical
shunts before PLT, TIPS before PLT increased the 1-year graft surviva
l. Surgical shunts alone were done in 18 patients with normal or near
normal liver function with 100% survival. TIPS alone offered effective
symptomatic relief to most patients, all of whom were judged not to b
e surgical candidates. Conclusions. TIPS, surgical shunts, and liver t
ransplantation each have a logical role in management of portal hypert
ension. Surgical candidates with Child's B or C liver failure should b
e treated with liver transplantation, and TIPS offers effective treatm
ent for nonsurgical candidates. Surgical shunts can be performed with
excellent results in patients with Child's A liver disease. Portal vei
n occlusion with normal liver function can be successfully treated wit
h surgical shunts.