Ja. Schmutz et al., RELATIVE EFFECTS OF SURVIVAL AND REPRODUCTION ON THE POPULATION-DYNAMICS OF EMPEROR GEESE, The Journal of wildlife management, 61(1), 1997, pp. 191-201
Populations of emperor geese (Chen canagica) in Alaska declined someti
me between the mid-1960s and the mid-1980s and have increased little s
ince. To promote recovery of this species to former levels, managers n
eed to know how much their perturbations of survival and/or reproducti
on would affect population growth rate (lambda). We constructed an ind
ividual-based population model to evaluate the relative effect of alte
ring mean values of various survival and reproductive parameters on la
mbda and fall age structure (AS, defined as the proportion of juv), as
suming additive rather than compensatory relations among parameters. A
ltering survival of adults had markedly greater relative effects on la
mbda than did equally proportionate changes in either juvenile surviva
l or reproductive parameters. We found the opposite pattern for relati
ve effects on AS. Due to concerns about bias in the initial parameter
estimates used in our model, we used 5 additional sets of parameter es
timates with this model structure. We found that estimates of survival
based on aerial survey data gathered each fall resulted in models tha
t corresponded more closely to independent estimates of lambda than di
d models that used mark-recapture estimates of survival. This disparit
y suggests that mark-recapture estimates of survival are biased low. T
o further explore how parameter estimates affected estimates of lambda
, we used values of survival and reproduction found in other goose spe
cies, and we examined the effect of an hypothesized correlation betwee
n an individual's clutch size and the subsequent survival of her young
. The rank order of parameters in their relative effects on lambda was
consistent for all 6 parameter sets we examined. The observed variati
on in relative effects on lambda among the 6 parameter sets is indicat
ive of how relative effects on lambda may vary among goose populations
. With this knowledge of the relative effects of survival and reproduc
tive parameters on lambda, managers can make more informed decisions a
bout which parameters to influence through management or to target for
future study.