M. Jobmann et C. Clauser, HEAT ADVECTION VERSUS CONDUCTION AT THE KTB - POSSIBLE REASONS FOR VERTICAL VARIATIONS IN HEAT-FLOW DENSITY, Geophysical journal international, 119(1), 1994, pp. 44-68
Data from the 4 km deep KTB pilot hole (VB) show a strong vertical var
iation in heat-flow density (HFD) by as much as 50 per cent. This may
be caused both by heat conduction, by advection, and by transient diff
usion. At the moment it is not possible to quantify exactly the contri
bution of each of these. However, 2-D simulations help to define the p
arameter ranges and structural features required if these processes ar
e to be thermally efficient. The main results are: (1) thermal conduct
ivity contrasts combined with structural heterogeneities as seen in th
e drilled profile give rise to steady-state, lateral refraction of hea
t. 2-D simulations of heat conduction indicate that this effect alone
is sufficiently strong to account for the observed variation of HFD wi
th depth. (2) Vertical Peclet number analyses of T-logs in shallow bor
eholes and the KTB-VB indicate a NE-SW flow of meteoric water across t
he Franconian Line (FL). However, average Peclet numbers of -0.37 +/-
0.13 in the potential recharge zone east of the FL are compatible with
2-D, steady-state simulations of heat and fluid flow only up to a dis
tance of about 10 km east of the FL, and only if a crystalline permeab
ility k(c) = 10(-14) m2 is assumed. (3) A permeability this high, howe
ver, is not confirmed by a comparison of temperature and HFD from nume
rical simulations and data from the KTB boreholes, neither for a model
focusing on shallow flow systems nor a deep structural model investig
ating potential contributions of convection in the entire upper crust.
(4) Alternatively, a joint inversion of T-logs from the same shallow
holes yields a ground-temperature history (GTH) that is in remarkably
good agreement with long-term meteorological records. (5) It appears,
therefore, as if the thermal regime at the KTB was generally dominated
by conduction, with additional advective, topography-driven contribut
ions mainly at shallow depths. The conductive regime, however, is a co
mplicated one, characterized by lateral heat flow due to structural he
terogeneity (and possibly anisotropy), and, at least at shallower dept
hs, by transient diffusion of paleoclimatic temperature signals into t
he subsurface.