H. Zincke et al., LONG-TERM (15 YEARS) RESULTS AFTER RADICAL PROSTATECTOMY FOR CLINICALLY LOCALIZED (STAGE-T2C OR LOWER) PROSTATE-CANCER, The Journal of urology, 152(5), 1994, pp. 1850-1857
To provide information about long-term outcome after radical prostatec
tomy for clinically localized prostatic cancer (stage T2c or lower), w
e undertook a retrospective analysis of 3,170 consecutive patients (me
an age 65.3 +/- 6.4 years, range 31 to 81) with a mean followup of 5 y
ears. Complication rates for patients who underwent prostatectomy befo
re 1988 were compared with those who underwent radical prostatectomy m
ore recently. Of the patients 49 (1.5%), 178 (5.6%), 897 (28%) and 2,0
47 (65%) had clinical stages Tla, T1b, T2a and T2b,c disease, respecti
vely. The Gleason score was 3 or less in 292 patients (9%) and 7 or gr
eater in 782 (25%). Overall, 438 patients (14%) died, 159 (5%) of canc
er. The crude 10 and 15-year survival rates for all patients were 75%
and 60%, respectively, which is comparable to the expected survival of
a control group (67% and 46%). The cause specific survival rates were
90% and 82%, respectively, metastasis-free survival rates 82% and 76%
, local recurrence-free survival rates 83% and 75%, overall recurrence
-free rates 72% and 61%, and overall recurrence plus prostate specific
antigen progression-free (greater than 0.2 ng./ml.) rates 52% and 40%
, respectively. Clinical stage did not significantly affect survival b
ut tumor grade was associated: 10 and 15-year cause specific survival
rates were 95% and 93%, respectively, for a Gleason score of 3 or less
, 90% and 82%, respectively, for a score of 4 to 6, and 82% and 71%, r
espectively, for a score of 7 or more. Of all patients 26% received ad
juvant treatment (hormonal and/or radiation) within 3 months postopera
tively because of advanced local pathological stage (pT3 or higher) or
margin positive disease. The 30-day mortality rate was 0.3% (0% for 1
,728 patients who underwent surgery in 1988 or later). Only 1 patient
in the 70 year or older age group died during hospitalization. Complic
ations decreased with time. In a contemporary group the complications
were rectal injury in 0.6% of the patients, colostomy in 0.06%, myocar
dial infarction in 0.4%, deep venous thrombosis in 1.1%, pulmonary emb
olism in 0.7% and total urinary incontinence (3 or more pads per day)
in 0.8%. Recent intraoperative blood loss was a median of 600 mi., and
the incidence of recent need for any transfusion was 31% and it is pr
esently less than 5%. In this series patients undergoing radical prost
atectomy for clinically localized prostate cancer were usually healthy
and, thus, had low co-morbidity. Survival rates at 10 and 15 years co
mpare favorably with those of an age-matched control group. Cause spec
ific and metastasis-free survival rates are excellent, even for patien
ts with undifferentiated cancer. Clinical tumor grade and co-morbidity
, rather than clinical stage, are significant variables for survival o
utcome. Present morbidity and mortality rates for radical prostatectom
y are minimal.