The proper approach to the diagnosis and treatment of localized prosta
te cancer is controversial and emotionally charged. The controversy fr
om a urological viewpoint is reviewed, and the future clinical studies
that must be done to prevent the disease, improve therapy and validat
e aggressive early diagnostic strategies are described briefly. It is
proposed that the greatest need for the future is a change in the atti
tudes of the participants. This attitudinal change must occur in sever
al areas: 1) a new determination to conduct the appropriate clinical t
rials, 2) different ways of conceptualizing the disease that better ex
plain the current screening data, paradox between cancer incidence and
lethality, and conflict between aggressive (United States) and conser
vative (Scandinavian) styles of management, and 3) renewed tolerance,
understanding and humility toward the different points of view.