M. Brandwein et al., HPV DETECTION USING HOT-START POLYMERASE CHAIN-REACTION IN PATIENTS WITH ORAL-CANCER - A CLINICOPATHOLOGICAL STUDY OF 64 PATIENTS, Modern pathology, 7(7), 1994, pp. 720-727
We examined the incidence of human papillomavirus (HPV) in intraoral c
ancers from 64 patients as determined by the highly sensitive techniqu
e of ''hot start'' polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in formalin-fixed p
araffin-embedded tissues. Polymerase-chain-reaction-amplified HPV DNA
was detected in the carcinomas of 16 patients (25%). The percentage of
men in the HPV-positive (HPV+) group was greater than that in the HPV
-negative (HPV-) group (86% versus 68%), but the difference was not st
atistically significant. There was no intraoral site preference for th
e HPV+ tumors. The mean age of viral-positive and -negative groups was
similar (55 versus 53.8 yr). Three of 16 HPV+ patients (19%) had neve
r smoked cigarettes; however, 16% of the HPV- group had also never smo
ked. Of interest, 38% of patients interviewed had occupation-related e
xposures that may have contributed to their carcinogenesis, and a disp
roportionate percentage of these patients (57%) were from the HPV+ gro
up. There were no statistically significant differences between HPV+ a
nd HPV- cases regarding T stage, clinical stage, and tumor differentia
tion. The disease-free interval did not differ significantly for HPVand HPV- patients in total nor when patients were stratified for tumor
stage and clinical stage. The only group that showed some difference
in outcome was that of the stage III/IV patients with oral cancer. We
observed a shorter survival time for the HPV+ patients as compared wit
h the HPV- patients (P = 0.09). We conclude that, in general, HPV is a
ssociated with a minority of intraoral cancers and its presence is not
predictive of patient outcome.