The selection and sequence of grammar remains an unresolved issue for
foreign language teachers. A survey of three leading German textbooks
revealed little coherence and lack of authenticity in the presentation
of the different German past tense forms. The present study offers an
empirical analysis of native speech data as a base for teaching the p
ast tense in German as a foreign language. Interviews with 75 native s
peakers showed that: 1) the present perfect serves as the dominant pas
t tense form for main verbs in the German colloquial standard; 2) moda
l verbs, the copula sein 'be,' haben 'have,' and certain formulaic exp
ression occur in the preterite; and 3) the use of the past tense forms
is linked to contextual and social factors. A German syllabus, then,
must include a discussion of verb type when presenting the everyday us
e of the German preterite and present perfect. The study points to the
situational and social contexts influencing the use of grammatical st
ructures rather than merely presenting contextless rules governing the
ir use.