The factor of safety for surficial stability is highly dependent on th
e effective cohesion. This study shows that even when triaxial tests a
re performed at effective pressures as low as 13.8 kPa (2.0 psi), the
results may still provide effective cohesion intercepts that are too h
igh. The reason is that the compacted sandy clay behaves as an overcon
solidated soil, with effective stress paths bending to the right with
low to negative A-values. As demonstrated by this case study of a surf
icial failure, the calculated factor of safety was 1.33 using the extr
apolated value of effective cohesion of 5.3 kPa (110 psf). An unconfin
ed submerged triaxial test resulted in a lower effective strength enve
lope, which provided a factor of safety of 0.97 for the surficial fail
ure. There are two factors that can increase the surficial stability o
f a compacted clay slope: aging and root reinforcement. For the surfic
ial failure, the effect of aging was minor and root reinforcement was
not a factor in this case, because the roots had not penetrated to a s
ignificant depth at the time of failure.