CHANGES IN THE ENDOCRINOLOGIC MILIEU AFTER CLOMIPHENE CITRATE TREATMENT FOR OLIGOZOOSPERMIA - THE CLINICAL-SIGNIFICANCE OF THE ESTRADIOL TESTOSTERONE RATIO AS A PROGNOSTIC VALUE/
N. Itoh et al., CHANGES IN THE ENDOCRINOLOGIC MILIEU AFTER CLOMIPHENE CITRATE TREATMENT FOR OLIGOZOOSPERMIA - THE CLINICAL-SIGNIFICANCE OF THE ESTRADIOL TESTOSTERONE RATIO AS A PROGNOSTIC VALUE/, Journal of andrology, 15(5), 1994, pp. 449-455
We have already reported that the rate of increase in the estradiol/te
stosterone ratio (E(2)/T ratio) following human chorionic gonadotropin
(hCG) injection has prognostic value in the treatment of oligozoosper
mia. It was found that the rate of increase in the E(2)/T ratio was st
atistically greater in the therapeutically ineffective cases compared
to the therapeutically effective cases. The present study was planned
in order to elucidate the relationship between the changes in the endo
crinological milieu, especially the change in the E(2)/T ratio, and th
e therapeutic efficacy when clomiphene citrate was administered. Thirt
y-eight oligozoospermic patients were administered 25 mg of clomiphene
citrate daily for 3 months. Sixteen of the 38 (42.1%) cases showed im
provement of more than 10 x 10(6)/ml in sperm concentration. The rate
of increase in the E(2)/T ratio of the effective cases (0.90 +/- 0.43)
during the administration of clomiphene citrate was statistically (P
= 0.02) lower than that of the ineffective cases (1.44 +/- 0.80). The
rate of increase in the E(2)/T ratio during clomiphene citrate treatme
nt showed a statistically positive correlation (r = 0.542) with the ra
te of increase following hCG injection performed before clomiphene cit
rate treatment. The rate of increase in follicle-stimulating hormone (
FSH) in the ineffective cases (2.16 +/- 1.01) was statistically higher
than in the effective cases (1.50 +/- 0.43). The rate of increase in
insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) in the seminal plasma that was se
creted by Sertoli cells was statistically higher in the effective case
s (1.98 +/- 1.23) than in the ineffective cases (1.19 +/- 0.45). Based
on these results, it is surmised that the relatively increased E(2) l
evel during clomiphene citrate treatment suppressed Sertoli cell funct
ion, and the serum FSH was elevated as a result. We concluded that the
rate of increase in the E(2)/T ratio during clomiphene citrate treatm
ent has prognostic value, and performing the hCG test before this trea
tment may be helpful in predicting the endocrinological milieu after i
t. If the rate of increase in the E(2)/T ratio following hCG injection
is high, treatment should consist of a combination of clomiphene citr
ate and an aromatase inhibitor to decrease the E(2)/T ratio.