This position paper by the American College of Physicians Task Force o
n Physician Supply examines expanded roles for physician assistants an
d nurse practitioners in light of projected shortages of primary healt
h care providers. Meta-analyses and other literature reviews comparing
the care provided by nurse practitioners and physician assistants wit
h that by primary care physicians had methodologic shortcomings that m
ade the data difficult to interpret. There were no studies comparing n
urse practitioners in independent practice with physicians. Seven poli
cy positions are articulated.