Re. Fournier et al., SHORT-RANGE VARIABILITY OF SOIL CHEMISTRY IN 3 ACID SOILS IN ONTARIO,CANADA, Communications in soil science and plant analysis, 25(17-18), 1994, pp. 3069-3082
The objective of this study was to assess the efficacy of soil samplin
g and analysis methodologies used in Canada's Acid Rain National Early
Warning System (ARNEWS). During July and August of 1992, twenty-five
soil pits were sampled and analyzed for available phosphorus (P); exch
angeable potassium (K), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), iron (Fe), coppe
r (Cu), manganese (Mn), zinc (Zn), aluminum (Al), sodium (Na), sulfate
-sulfur (SO4-S), boron (B), and molybdenum (Mo); total nitrogen (N), P
, K, Ca, Mg, Fe, Cu, Mn, Zn, Al, Na, sulfur (S), B, nickel (Ni), lead
(Pb), and organic matter (O.M.); pH; and cation exchange capacity (C.E
.C.) at three ARNEWS sites across Ontario. The soils were: i) a till-d
erived Ferro-Humic Podzol (Humic Haplorthod), ii) a Humo-Ferric Podzol
(Haplorthod) developed in coarse glaciofluvial sand, and iii) a Dystr
ic Brunisol (Dystrochrept). The three sites were similar in chemical c
omposition except for available P, exchangeable Ca, Mn, total Mn, O.M.
, and pH. Sample numbers calculated to achieve +/-10% error with 95% c
onfidence were much higher in mineral horizons than in forest-floor ho
rizons. Organic macro-elements and pH were found to be the least varia
ble parameters while micro-elements were significantly more variable.
Analyses are categorized into groups requiring similar numbers of samp
les. Other studies have found comparable levels of variability and the
ir results are compared to coefficients of variation generated by the
Ontario results. Variability within a pit was also observed and found
to be less than that found across each 20- x 20-m site but still very
significant. Overall, the variability results from other studies appea
r to be applicable to Ontario acid soils for common analyses. Investig
ations observing micro-elements, or which require high levels of accur
acy, should incorporate pilot studies to ascertain the degree of varia
bility for their location.