G. Worthey, COMPREHENSIVE STELLAR POPULATION-MODELS AND THE DISENTANGLEMENT OF AGE AND METALLICITY EFFECTS, The Astrophysical journal. Supplement series, 95(1), 1994, pp. 107-149
The construction of detailed models for intermediate and old stellar p
opulations is described. Input parameters include metallicity (-2 < [F
e/H] (0.5), single-burst age (between 1.5 and 17 Gyr), and initial mas
s function (IMF) exponent. Quantities output include broadband magnitu
des, spectral energy distributions, surface brightness fluctuation mag
nitudes, and a suite of 21 absorption feature indices. The models are
checked against a wide variety of available observations. Examinations
of model output yield the following conclusions. (1) If the percentag
e change Delta age/Delta Z approximate to 3/2 for two populations, the
y will appear almost identical in most indices. A few indices break th
is degeneracy by being either more abundance sensitive (Fe4668, Fe5015
, Fe5709, and Fe5782) or more age sensitive (G4300, H beta, and presum
ably higher order Balmer lines) than usual. (2) Present uncertainties
in stellar evolution are of the same magnitude as the effects of IMF a
nd Y in the indices studied. (3) Changes in abundance ratios (like [Mg
/Fe]) are predicted to be readily apparent in the spectra of old stell
ar populations. (4) The I-band flux of a stellar population is predict
ed to be nearly independent of metallicity and only modestly sensitive
to age. The I band is therefore recommended for standard candle work
or studies of M/L in galaxies. Other conclusions stem from this work.
(1) Intercomparison of models and observations of two TiO indices seem
to indicate variation of the [V/Ti] ratio among galaxies, but it is n
ot clear how this observation ties into the standard picture of chemic
al enrichment. (2) Current estimates of [Fe/H] for the most metal-rich
globulars that are based on integrated indices are probably slightly
too high. (3) Colors of population models from different authors exhib
it a substantial range. At solar metallicity and 13 Gyr, this range co
rresponds to an age error of roughly +/-7 Gyr. Model colors from diffe
rent authors applied in a differential sense have smaller uncertaintie
s. (4) In the present models the dominant error for colors is probably
the transformation from stellar atmospheric parameters to stellar col
ors. (5) Stellar B - V is difficult to model, and current spreads amon
g different authors can reach 0.2 mag. (6) If known defects in the ste
llar nux library are corrected, the population model colors of this wo
rk in passbands redder than U would be accurate to roughly 0.03 mag in
an absolute sense. These corrections are not made in the tables of mo
del output.