A. Bagur et al., AGE-DEPENDENCE OF THE NORMAL ABNORMAL DIFFERENCE OF BONE-MINERAL DENSITY IN OSTEOPOROTIC WOMEN/, Bone and mineral, 26(3), 1994, pp. 209-218
Bone mineral density (BMD) is the major factor in bone strength and in
the risk of suffering osteoporotic fractures. The aim of this study w
as to examine the normal/abnormal difference for antero-posterior (AP)
spine, lateral spine, proximal femur and total body BMD to assess if
age influences discrimination at three different decades between 50 an
d 80 years of age. The BMD was determined in 61 control women and 60 o
steoporotic women (at least one vertebral wedge fracture readily visib
le in the lateral X-rays of the thoracic or lumbar spine). Measurement
s were made by DEXA with a total body scanner. The BMD of the whole gr
oup of osteoporotic women was markedly lower than that of age-matched
controls at all skeletal areas (P < 0.001) except at the arms where th
e difference was smaller (P < 0.02). The Z-score (the difference betwe
en osteoporotic patients and age-matched control divided by the intrap
opulation S.D.) was similar (similar to -1.7) over the AP spine, femor
al neck, Ward's triangle, total body and legs. It was significantly lo
wer at the arms (-0.8, P < 0.001), lateral spine (-1.4, P < 0.01) and
trochanter (-1.3, P < 0.001) compared with the Z-score of the AP spine
. The analysis of the results by decades of age disclosed that the hig
her Z-score on the 6th and 7th decades corresponded to the AP lumbar s
pine (similar to -2.0). A high descrimination was also observed for th
e femoral neck, Ward's triangle and legs while the Z-score of the late
ral lumbar spine, total body, trochanter and arms were significantly l
ower than that of the AP lumbar spine. However on the 8th decade the Z
-score of the AP lumbar spine diminished to -1.2 and was only signific
antly higher than the Z-score of the arms (P < 0.01). The study showed
that, in women 50-60 years of age - the period where the majority of
studies are made for prevention of osteoporosis, none of the other ske
letal areas were superior to the AP spine in discrimination for spinal
osteoporosis. Proximal femur and legs densitometry gave lower but not
significantly different Z-score than the AP spine, while the remainin
g areas were significantly inferior to AP spine in separating osteopor
otic and normal women.