Jj. Morales et al., HOW THE CHOICE OF SHAPE AND ENSEMBLE AFFECT SIMULATIONS OF 2-DIMENSIONAL MELTING, Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics, 50(4), 1994, pp. 2844-2848
Nonequilibrium quenching in two-dimensional simulations from a solid o
r liquid to an interfacial-hexatic regime demonstrates the sensitivity
of the final results to the shape of the simulation box (final size e
ffect) and to the molecular dynamics ensemble used (constant density v
ersus constant pressure). Even for a small system of N = 1024 particle
s, under no circumstance is stabilization of the structure factor reac
hed before some nanoseconds. This means that the results given by Naid
oo et al. [Mel. Phys. 80, 1 (1993)] using hexatic structure boundaries
are too small and pose the question of whether all the published work
on two-dimensional melting has used systems that are too small and si
mulation times that are too short.