The growth energetics of carbon nanotubes during are discharge conditi
ons are investigated. Ab initio molecular dynamics calculations show t
hat the electric field alone cannot stabilize the growth of open metal
lic tubes. The addition of atoms and small clusters to tubes were stud
ied using realistic atomic potentials. Deposition on tubes narrower th
an similar to 3 nm leads to nucleation of curved defects (adjacent pen
tagon pairs) and eventual tube closure, while deposition on wider tube
s favors the formation of hexagons and isolated pentagons, thereby pro
moting open-ended growth.