C. Bressac et al., ANOTHER WAY OF BEING ANISOGAMOUS IN DROSOPHILA SUBGENUS SPECIES - GIANT SPERM, ONE-TO-ONE GAMETE RATIO, AND HIGH ZYGOTE PROVISIONING, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United Statesof America, 91(22), 1994, pp. 10399-10402
It is generally assumed that sexes in animals have arisen from a produ
ctivity versus provisioning conflict; males are those individuals prod
ucing gametes necessarily small, in excess, and individually bereft of
all paternity assurance. A 1- to 2-cm sperm, 5-10 times as long as th
e male body, might therefore appear an evolutionary paradox. As a matt
er of fact, species of Drosophila of the Drosophila subgenus differ fr
om those of other subgenera by producing exclusively sperm of that sor
t. We report counts of such giant costly sperm in Drosophila littorali
s and Drosophila hydei females, indicating that they are offered in ex
ceedingly small amounts, tending to a one-to-one gamete ratio after a
single mating. As a result, most of them are successfully involved in
a fertilization. Hence, the concept of ''paternity assurance of indivi
dual sperm'' arises. Evidence is further provided here that almost the
entire sperm is incorporated into the egg during fertilization. Label
ing with specific antibodies in fertilized eggs reveals intact axoneme
s up to late gastrulation. The question, then, is why selection has fa
vored such an unusual strategy. Explanations related to some prefertil
ization functions are ruled out. It is therefore tentatively proposed
that virtually every giant sperm constitutes a ''direct paternal legac
y to the embryo,'' which, in contrast to any male-derived nuptial gift
, cannot be minimized by female remating. We suggest that dramatic sho
rtage of giant sperm with a high prospect of fusion and increased zygo
te provisioning is merely another way of being anisogamous.