A previous study questioned whether the published forecasts of one for
ecasting organization were valuable to users. A forecast was considere
d valuable if it differed significantly from a naive model in the sens
e of predicting the direction of change. The results indicated that it
was not possible to show that the one-quarter-ahead predictions were
valuable. However, the current-quarter forecasts were valuable. This p
aper examines whether the results are robust. The forecasts of two add
itional organizations were examined and the time period was extended.
The results are generally robust.