A shallow P-wave seismic source comparison was conducted at a site nea
r Houston, Texas where the depth to the water table was approximately
7 m, and near-surface materials consisted of clays, sands, and gravels
. Data from twelve different sources during this November 1991 compari
son are displayed and analyzed. Reflection events are interpretable at
about 40 ms on some 220-Hz analog low-cut filtered field files, and a
t 60 ms on most 110- and 220-Hz analog low-cut filtered field files. C
alculations and local water well information suggest the 40-ms event i
s from the top of the water table. Subsurface explosive sources seem t
o possess the highest dominant frequency, broadest bandwidth, and reco
rded amplitudes and, therefore, have the greatest resolution potential
at this site. Our previous work and that of our colleagues suggests t
hat, given a specific set of site characteristics, any source could do
minate the comparison categories addressed here.