Objective: To examine possible causes for factitious human immunodefic
iency virus (HIV) infection among patients in an HIV clinic. Design: R
etrospective chart review, a case-control study, and a survey of local
hospital practices for documenting HIV infection. Setting: Clinical a
cquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) program at a municipal hospit
al. Results: Seven patients with self-reported, undocumented HIV infec
tion were identified as HIV seronegative after a mean of 9.2 months of
care in our clinical AIDS program. The median CD4 count for these pat
ients was 740 cells/mm(3); 6 patients had a history of illicit narcoti
c use and clinical symptoms consistent with HIV disease. Compared with
70 randomly selected controls from HIV clinics, patients with factiti
ous HIV infection had higher CD4 counts (difference, 519 cells/mm(3);
P < 0.001) and were more likely to have an HIV-infected sexual partner
(odds ratio, 15.0; P = 0.005) and a history of a suicide attempt (odd
s ratio, 9.8; P = 0.02). Known cases of alleged HIV infection have occ
urred at 8 of the 10 other local hospitals surveyed. However, only 1 o
f the 10 hospitals routinely documented HIV infection in patients befo
re initiating care. Conclusions: Limitations of the current serologic
tests for HIV, the use of anonymous HIV testing, and recent reports of
factitious HIV disease or immune deficiency syndromes that may mimic
AIDS underscore the need for clear documentation of HIV infection befo
re medical care is started.