Ep. Hamerlynck et Ak. Knapp, LEAF-LEVEL RESPONSES TO LIGHT AND TEMPERATURE IN 2 COOCCURRING QUERCUS (FAGACEAE) SPECIES - IMPLICATIONS FOR TREE DISTRIBUTION PATTERNS, Forest ecology and management, 68(2-3), 1994, pp. 149-159
Leaf-level responses to light environment (sun vs. shade) and high tem
perature were compared in two gallery forest oaks, bur oak (Quercus ma
crocarpa) and chinquapin oak (Quercus muehlenbergii). Our goal was to
determine if species-specific differences in response to light or temp
erature could explain the distribution of these oaks in tallgrass prai
rie gallery forests. On the Konza Prairie Research Natural Area in NE
Kansas (USA), bur oak is more abundant than chinquapin oak along lower
reaches of streams where the forests are most productive and canopy c
losure is greatest. We hypothesized that bur oak is better able to acc
limate physiologically to reduced light availability than chinquapin o
ak. Leaf level acclimation to low light in both oaks occurred through
reduced photosynthetic light compensation points (PLC) (bur oak, 60.77
+/-3.02 mu mol photons m(-2) s(-1) in sun leaves vs. 29.25+/-0.29 phot
ons m(-2) s(-1) in shade leaves; chinquapin oak, 49.47+/-2.82 photons
m(-2) s(-1) in sun leaves vs. 26.48+/-1.74 photons m(-2) s(-1) in shad
e leaves), resulting from nearly 50% reductions in dark respiration an
d specific leaf mass in both species. Apparent quantum requirement (Q(
req); mol photons mol(-1) O-2) did not differ between sun and shade le
aves in either species, and only bur oak showed differences in sun and
shade leaf shape. We also hypothesized that chinquapin oak, which is
more abundant in exposed, upper stream reaches, has greater photosynth
etic tolerance to the high temperatures characteristic of this region.
The maximum temperature tolerances (T-max) of these oaks were compare
d by measuring increases in chlorophyll fluorescence. For most of the
growing season, T-max in chinquapin oak was 2.0 degrees C higher than
in bur oak. Field measurements of leaf vs. air temperatures in seedlin
gs and adult trees indicated that T-max was more likely to be exceeded
in bur than in chinquapin oak, particularly in seedlings exposed to h
igh solar radiation loads. We concluded that differences in thermal to
lerance, in addition to previously documented differences in water rel
ations are important determinants of distributional patterns of these
oaks within gallery forests.