Rr. Snook et al., FUNCTIONAL NONEQUIVALENCE OF SPERM IN DROSOPHILA-PSEUDOOBSCURA, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United Statesof America, 91(23), 1994, pp. 11222-11226
We report on a form of sperm polymorphism, termed polymegaly, that occ
urs is species of the Drosophila obscura group. Individual males of sp
ecies in this group characteristically produce more than one discrete
length of nucleated, motile sperm. Hypotheses suggested to explain the
evolutionary significance of sperm polymorphism have been either nona
daptive or adaptive, with the latter focusing on sperm competition or
nutrient provisioning. These hypotheses assume all sperm types fertili
ze eggs; however, no data have been gathered to test this assumption.
We found that two size classes of sperm are produced and transferred t
o females in approximately equal numbers by the male; only long sperm
persist in significant numbers in female sperm storage organs. Further
more, we used a DNA-specific dye (bisbenzimide) and sperm-specific ant
ibodies to ask if both sperm types fertilize eggs in Drosophila pseudo
obscura. Confocal microscopy and immunofluorescent analyses of fertili
zed eggs using anti-sperm polyclonal antisera demonstrated that only l
ong sperm participate in fertilization. These data falsify those hypot
heses in which all sperm types are assumed to be functionally equivale
nt (fertilize eggs). Any remaining or new hypotheses for the evolution
ary significance of polymegaly must incorporate these findings. Severa
l new areas of research are suggested.