Sl. Brown et al., PHYTOREMEDIATION POTENTIAL OF THLASPI-CAERULESCENS AND BLADDER CAMPION FOR ZINC-CONTAMINATED AND CADMIUM-CONTAMINATED SOIL, Journal of environmental quality, 23(6), 1994, pp. 1151-1157
Metal-tolerant hyperaccumulator plants may be useful to phyto-remediat
e contaminated soils. To evaluate agronomic management practices to ma
ximize phytoremediation, two metallophytes, Thlaspi caerulescens J. an
d C. Presl (Zn hyperaccumulator) and bladder campion [Silene vulgaris
(Moench) Garcke L.] (an indicator) were compared to 'Rutgers' tomato (
Lycopersicon esculentum L.) in a pot study to assess Zn and Cd uptake
patterns in relation to soil pH. Soils used for the study were gathere
d at three different sites in the vicinity of an old Zn smelter in Pal
merton, PA, and contained 48 000, 4100, and 2100 mg kg(-1) Zn and 1020
, 37.4, and 35.2 mg kg(-1) Cd, respectively . Each soil was adjusted t
o three pH levels ranging from 5.06 to 7.04. Thlaspi caerulescens show
ed much greater tolerance to the metals than the other plants (up to 1
8 455 mg kg(-1) Zn and 1020 mg kg(-1) Cd dry shoots without yield redu
ction) with metal stress apparent only in the low pH treatments of the
two most contaminated soils. In all treatments except for the farm so
il (least contaminated) at pH 5.06, T. caerulescens had higher concent
rations of both Zn and Cd than bladder campion and tomato. Thlaspi cae
rulescens was also more effective at translocating both Zn and Cd from
soil to plant shoots. A variety of soil extractions were used to eval
uate the correlation of shoot metal concentrations with quantitative m
easures of ''available'' soil metals. Concentrations of Cd measured in
several common extractants (DTPA, water, 0.01 M Ca(NO3)(2), and 1.0 M
NH4NO3) were significantly correlated with Cd concentrations in tissu
e of each plant. Shoot Zn concentrations of bladder campion and tomato
were significantly correlated with Zn extracted by the neutral salt e
xtractants for all soils. For T. caerulescens, the neutral salt extrac
table Zn was significantly correlated with shoot Zn only in the two mo
re contaminated soils. No extractant predicted shoot Zn concentration
for T. caerulescens in the least contaminated soil.