I. Grillier et al., ALTERATIONS OF DIFFERENTIATION, CLONAL PROLIFERATION, CELL-CYCLE PROGRESSION AND BCL-2 EXPRESSION IN RAR-ALPHA-ALTERED SUBLINES OF HL-60, Leukemia, 11(3), 1997, pp. 393-400
All-trans retinoic acid (RA) induces granulocytic differentiation of a
cute promyelocytic leukemia cells both in vivo and in vitro. In the HL
-60 wild-type (WT) early promyelocytic leukemia cell line, granulocyti
c differentiation appears to be directly mediated by the nuclear recep
tor RAR alpha. An HL-60 subline resistant to RA (HL-60 R) contains a p
oint mutation which results in a truncation of 52 amino acids at the C
OOH end of RAR alpha. Cross-talk between differentiation, clonal inhib
ition of growth and apoptosis was studied using HL-60 WT, HL-60 R, and
HL-60 R infected by a retroviral vector containing RAR alpha (LX) as
targets, which were cultured with various retinoids, vitamin D-3 analo
gs, HMBA, or DMSO. None of these compounds induced significant differe
ntiation of HL-60 R and HL-60 LX, but they did induce differentiation
of HL-60 WT. In contrast, retinoids inhibited the clonal proliferation
of HL-60 WT, HL-60 R, and HL-60 LX. Vitamin D-3 analogs including KH1
060 stimulated the clonal growth of HL-60 R; but they inhibited clonal
growth of HL-60 WT and LX. Levels of Bcl-2 strongly decreased in HL-6
0 WT and LX after treatment by retinoids, while no change in expressio
n occurred in HL-60 R. Neither KH 1060 nor 9-cis RA induced apoptosis
of HL-60 R, but these agents did induce apoptosis in HL-60 LX WT. Take
n together, we showed that HL-60 R has a global defect in its ability
to be induced to differentiate by a variety of pathways, not merely th
e retinoid pathway. Furthermore, our HL-60 models showed that inhibiti
on of proliferation and induction of apoptosis and differentiation can
be dissociated. Clinically, these results suggest that several putati
ve differentiation agents may have anti-cancer (antiproliferative) act
ivities, even though they do not induce differentiation of the cancer
cells.