Yi. Izotov et al., THE PRIMORDIAL HELIUM ABUNDANCE FROM A NEW SAMPLE OF METAL-DEFICIENT BLUE COMPACT GALAXIES, The Astrophysical journal, 435(2), 1994, pp. 647-667
We use high-quality spectrophotometric observations of 10 low-metallic
ity blue compact galaxies (BCGs) with oxygen abundance ranging from 12
+ log(O/H) = 7.37 to 8.04 to determine the primordial helium abundanc
e. We take special care into investigating the physical effects which
may affect such a determination. We find that underlying stellar absor
ption, enhancement of helium lines due to self-absorption, and correct
ions for neutral and doubly ionized helium to be negligible. The main
physical mechanism changing the He I line intensities from their recom
bination values is collisional excitation. To correct for it, we calcu
late the electron number density in the He+ zone by a self-consistent
procedure which constrains the He I lambda 5876/lambda 4471, lambda 66
78/lambda 4471 and lambda 7065/lambda 4471 line ratios to have their r
ecombination values, after correction for collisional enhancement. The
density sensitive He I lambda 7065 line plays an important role in th
is respect. The usual practice of using the electron number density de
rived from the [S II] lambda 6717/lambda 6731 ratio underestimates the
collisional enhancement correction and hence overestimates the helium
abundance by similar to 5%. We find that Brocklehurst's (1972) He I r
ecombination emissivities give a smaller dispersion of the data points
in the Y versus O/H and Y versus N/H planes and within the derived He
abundances from different lines in a given galaxy than Smits's old (1
991a, b) emissivities. The dispersion is comparable when Smits's new (
1994) emissivities are used. By taking the mean of the intercepts of b
oth Y versus O/H and Y versus N/H linear regressions at O/H = N/H = 0,
we determine a primordial helium mass fraction Y-p = 0.229 +/- 0.004,
with Brocklehurst's emissivities, and Y-p = 0.240 +/- 0.005 with Smit
s's new emissivities. Taking the mean Y of the four most metal-deficie
nt BCGs (Z < Z(.)/15) in our sample gives Y-p = 0.233 +/- 0.003 with B
rocklehurst's emissivities. Adding the four known BCGs with Z < Z(.)/1
5 from the literature yields: Y-p = 0.232 +/- 0.002. These determinati
ons are consistent with the lower limit of Y-p = 0.236 required by sta
ndard big bang nucleosynthesis theory. We obtain a slope dY/dZ = 5.8 /- 1.7 with Brocklehurst's emissivities and dY/dZ = 5.8 +/- 4.4 with S
mits' new emissivities, larger than the values predicted by closed-box
models, but consistent with those given by chemical evolution models
with differential galactic winds.