BILIRUBIN, FERRITIN, D-DIMERS AND ERYTHROPHAGES IN THE CEREBROSPINAL-FLUID OF PATIENTS WITH SUSPECTED SUBARACHNOID HEMORRHAGE BUT NEGATIVE COMPUTED-TOMOGRAPHY SCANS
Kb. Page et al., BILIRUBIN, FERRITIN, D-DIMERS AND ERYTHROPHAGES IN THE CEREBROSPINAL-FLUID OF PATIENTS WITH SUSPECTED SUBARACHNOID HEMORRHAGE BUT NEGATIVE COMPUTED-TOMOGRAPHY SCANS, Journal of Clinical Pathology, 47(11), 1994, pp. 986-989
Aim-To assess the diagnostic value of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) spectr
ophotometry, cytology, ferritin, and D-dimer measurements in the inves
tigation of suspected subarachnoid haemorrhage in patients with negati
ve or equivocal computed tomography (CT) scans. Methods-CSF specimens
submitted for assessment of xanthochromia were examined for erythropha
ges using a cytospin preparation stained with Wright's stain, for ferr
itin using the Ciba-Corning Magic IRMA assay, D-dimers using the Dimer
test 2 latex agglutination slide test, and for bilirubin by scanning s
pectrophotometry. The patients were divided into three groups for data
analysis and the results compared with the existing methods, CT, and
angiogram results. Final diagnoses were reviewed by a consultant neuro
logist. Results-Thirty six patients were recruited. In those patients
with confirmed subarachnoid haemorrhage CSF cytology had a low sensiti
vity and there were false negative results with both the D-dimer and f
erritin assays. Eleven patients with a negative or equivocal CT scan u
nderwent angiography, but only one aneurysm and no arterio-venous malf
ormations or bleeding points were identified. In the patient with the
aneurysm there was no laboratory evidence of subarachnoid haemorrhage.
Six patients had CSF abnormalities detected by the special tests only
and in none of these cases was subarachnoid haemorrhage confirmed. Ah
results were normal in four out of five cases of traumatic tap. Concl
usions-This is a small study, but it shows that, depending on the timi
ng of the lumbar puncture, false negative results can occur with both
ferritin and D-dimer measurements. It suggests that neither of these t
ests adds significantly to the information provided by CT, visualisati
on of CSF, and spectrophotometry and confirms that, despite the use of
spectrophotometry, D-dimer and ferritin assays in selecting patients
for angiography, the proportion of patients with negative CT scans and
colourless CSF with demonstrable vascular lesions remains low.