This study explores the meaning of police estimates of gang membership
, by reviewing the characteristics of youth labeled as gang members in
one western state, Hawaii, during 1991. Arrest patterns of these yout
h do not support the notion that they constitute a seriously violent s
ubset of criminals. Indeed, nearly a third had not been arrested in th
e previous three years; notable too is the absence of a large number o
f weapon or drug arrests. These findings are amplified by data from a
comparison of youth who were not labeled as gang members; these indica
te that youth (in the City and County of Honolulu) who are delinquent
differ little from those youth suspected of gang membership in terms o
f the frequency or severity of their offenses. Finally, the groups mos
t commonly labeled by police as gang members are Filipino and Samoan m
ales, but self-report data on gang membership indicate a somewhat diff
erent ethnic composition. The policy implications of these findings ar
e also discussed.