A. Schutz et al., CYTOIMMUNOLOGICAL MONITORING AFTER HOMOGRAFT VALVE-REPLACEMENT, European journal of cardio-thoracic surgery, 8(11), 1994, pp. 609-612
Examination results concerning immunological reactions in cryopreserve
d allograft valves during the early postoperative course are so far no
t available. Cytoimmunological monitoring (CIM) is a well established
method to prove rejection reaction after allograft transplantation and
was used in this study. Allograft valves were harvested from patients
who underwent heart transplantation, and did not require sterilizing
in antibiotic solutions. The valves were dissected, conserved and subs
equently frozen to -40-degrees-C and stored in a freezing system at -1
96-degrees-C. During the first 3 weeks following allograft implantatio
n, CIM was performed daily. An activation index (AI) was determined fr
om the cytological evaluation of the mononuclear concentrate in the pe
ripheral blood. An increase of the AI>1 was defined as an immunologica
l reaction. As control we performed 98 CIM examinations in eight patie
nts who underwent bioprosthetic valve replacement in the aortic positi
on. Echocardiography (TTE and TEE) was used postoperatively as functio
n control. Out of 16 patients who underwent cryopreserved aortic valve
implantation in the aortic position, 336 CIM-results were obtained. A
n immunological reaction could be detected in all patients, starting o
n the 5th day on average. Comparing ABO-compatible (group I, n=9) with
ABO-incompatible (group II, n=7) allografts, the AI-maximum in group
I was 1.4 with a mean duration of 1.5 days. Group II was characterized
by more intensive immunoreactions (xBAR=2.3) which proved to be even
more prolonged (xBAR=3.3 days, P<0.05). Nevertheless it became apparen
t that all observed immunological events were completely reversible wi
thout the need for immunosuppressive drugs. Cytoimmunological monitori
ng control in patients after bioprosthetic valve replacement did not s
how any signs of activation (n=98, xBAR=0.1). Routine echocardiography
demonstrated a regular function and morphology of the implanted allog
rafts in 14 cases after 3 months. A hemodynamically irrelevant valve i
nsufficiency could be detected in two patients. Allograft valves Gener
ally cause immunological reactions in contrast to xenogeneic bioprosth
eses as measured in the CIM routine test. The activation index of ABO-
incompatible allografts shows significantly more and longer elevation.
The immunological reactions reverse spontaneously without any use of
immunosuppression. A different ABO-system does not alter the function
and morpholoy of the allograft valves early postoperatively. However,
the role of ABO tissue-matching should be clarified in the long-term f
ollow-up.