Ed. Glendening et al., AN AB-INITIO INVESTIGATION OF THE STRUCTURE AND ALKALI-METAL CATION SELECTIVITY OF 18-CROWN-6, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 116(23), 1994, pp. 10657-10669
We present an ab initio, quantum mechanical study of 18-crown-6 (18c6)
and its interaction with the alkali metal cations Li+, Na+, K+, Rb+,
and Cs+. Geometries, binding energies, and binding enthalpies are eval
uated at the restricted Hartree-Fock (RHF) level using standard basis
sets (3-21G and 6-31+G) and relativistic effective core potentials. E
lectron correlation effects are determined at the MP2 level, and wave
function analysis is performed by the natural bond orbital (NBO) and a
ssociated methods. The affinity of 18c6 for the alkali metal cations i
s quite strong (50-100 kcal mol(-1), depending on cation type), arisin
g largely from the electrostatic (ionic) interaction of the cation wit
h the nucleophilic ether backbone. Charge transfer (covalent bonding)
contributions are somewhat less important, only 20-50% as strong as th
e electrostatic interaction. Agreement of the calculated binding entha
lpies and experimentally determined quantities is rather poor. For exa
mple, the binding energy for K+/18c6 (-71.5 kcal mol(-1)) is about 30
kcal mol(-1) stronger than that determined by experiment, and it is no
t clear how to reconcile this difference. Our calculations clearly sho
w that solvation effects strongly influence cation selectivity. Gas-ph
ase 18c6 preferentially binds Li+, not K+ as found in aqueous environm
ents. We show, however, that K+ selectivity is recovered when even a f
ew waters of hydration are considered.