X. Jia et al., FINITE-ELEMENT SIMULATION OF SIGMA-60 HEATING IN THE UTAH PHANTOM - COMPUTED AND MEASURED DATA COMPARED, International journal of hyperthermia, 10(6), 1994, pp. 755-774
An initial series of comparisons are made between finite element compu
tations and laboratory measurements obtained during heterogeneous phan
tom heating with the Sigma 60 applicator. The phantom is a relatively
complex, though still idealized, rendering of the pelvic area which ha
s been used to study the deep heating characteristics of the Sigma 60
in this anatomy. Direct electric field measurements as well as inferre
d SAR through transient temperature analysis are plotted against compu
ted results along 11 one-dimensional tracks through the phantom. Quant
itative comparisons provided through the track-by-track analysis show
generally good agreement between computation and measurement. The fini
te element method is found to predict well the jumps in the electric f
ield when polarized perpendicularly to a muscle/fat interface. Visuali
zations of the complete three-dimensional distributions are also highl
ighted and correlate well with physical reasoning about the expected b
ehaviour of the fields produced. Some discrepancies in the data persis
t and are discussed and analysed in depth. They underscore the difficu
lties that can arise in performing comparisons between measured and co
mputed results and stress the need for careful and thorough investigat
ions when attempting these types of model validation studies.