Em. Saffran et Mf. Schwartz, IMPAIRMENTS OF SENTENCE COMPREHENSION, Philosophical transactions-Royal Society of London. Biological sciences, 346(1315), 1994, pp. 47-53
We examine two different forms of comprehension impairment, 'semantic
dementia' and 'asyntactic comprehension', focusing on the assignment o
f thematic roles: the determination of who did it to whom. We show, fi
rst, that the loss of word meaning does not impede thematic assignment
in semantic dementia, demonstrating that syntactic information, along
with some knowledge of the verb, is sufficient for the assignment of
thematic roles. Studies of normal subjects indicate, however, that thi
s process is normally subject to semantic influences; asked to judge t
he plausibility of sentences, subjects respond faster when thematic as
signment is semantically constrained. The sentence plausibility judgme
nts of 'asyntactic' comprehenders (aphasics with diminished syntactic
control over thematic assignment) show increased effects of these sema
ntic constraints. We discuss these results in relation to current issu
es in sentence processing.