Ja. Small et al., SENTENCE COMPREHENSION IN ALZHEIMERS-DISEASE - EFFECTS OF GRAMMATICALCOMPLEXITY, SPEECH RATE, AND REPETITION, Psychology and aging, 12(1), 1997, pp. 3-11
Caregivers of patients diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease (AD) are oft
en advised to modify their speech to facilitate the patients' sentence
comprehension. Three common recommendations are to (a) speak in simpl
e sentences, (b) speak slowly, and (c) repeat one's utterance, using t
he same words. These three speech modifications were experimentally ma
nipulated in order to investigate their individual and combined effect
s on sentence comprehension in AD. Fifteen patients with mild to moder
ate AD and 20 healthy older persons were tested on a sentence comprehe
nsion task with sentences varying in terms of(a) degree of grammatical
complexity, (b) rate of presentation (normal vs, slow), and (c) form
of repetition (verbatim vs. paraphrase). The results indicated a signi
ficant decline in sentence comprehension for the AD group. Sentence co
mprehension improved, however, after the sentence was repeated in eith
er verbatim or paraphrased form. However, the patients' comprehension
did not improve for sentences presented at the slow speech rate. This
pattern of results is explained vis-a-vis the patients' working memory
loss. The findings challenge the appropriateness of several clinical
recommendations.