We have carried out kinetics studies of spinach carbonic anhydrase (CA
) using stopped-flow spectrophotometry at steady state and C-13-NMR ex
change at chemical equilibrium. We found that the rate of CO2 reversib
le arrow HCO3- exchange catalyzed by spinach CA at pH 7.0 to be 3-5 ti
mes faster than the maximal k(cat) for either CO2 hydration or HCO3- d
ehydration at steady state, suggesting a rate-determining H+ transfer
step in the catalytic mechanism. Correspondingly, we measured a pH-ind
ependent solvent deuterium isotope effect on k(cat) of approximately 2
.0, and found that the rate of catalysis was significantly decreased a
t external buffer concentrations below 5 mM. Our results are consisten
t with a zinc-hydroxide mechanism of action with for spinach CA, simil
ar to that of animal carbonic anhydrases. We have also collected X-ray
absorption spectra of spinach CA. Analysis of the extended fine struc
ture (EXAFS) suggests that the coordination sphere of Zn in spinach CA
must have one or more sulfur ligands, in contrast to animal CAs which
have only nitrogen and oxygen ligands. The models which best fit the
data have average Zn-N(O) distances of 1.99-2.06 Angstrom, average Zn-
S distances of 2.31-2.32 Angstrom, and a total coordination number of
4-6. We conclude that animal and spinach CAs are convergently evolved
enzymes which are structurally quite different, but functionally equiv
alent.