Sl. Greenspan et al., TROCHANTERIC BONE-MINERAL DENSITY IS ASSOCIATED WITH TYPE OF HIP FRACTURE IN THE ELDERLY, Journal of bone and mineral research, 9(12), 1994, pp. 1889-1894
Hip fractures can be separated into femoral neck (cervical or intracap
sular) or trochanteric (extracapsular). Trochanteric fractures have be
en associated with up to twice the short-term mortality of cervical fr
actures in the elderly. Fracture type may be influenced by the fall di
rection and local differences in proximal femur strength properties. W
e previously demonstrated that fall characteristics and body habitus,
in addition to femoral bone mineral density, play a dominant role in t
he prediction of hip fracture in elderly fallers. To examine the assoc
iation of these determinants with hip fracture type, we assessed fall
characteristics, body habitus, and site-specific bone mineral density
measurements in 112 elderly hip fracture patients (85 women and 27 men
, mean age 85 years) 1 week after an acute hip fracture. Trochanteric
BMD was 13% lower in women and 11% lower in men for patients with troc
hanteric fracture than in those with femoral neck fracture (p < 0.01).
A stepwise multiple logistic regression indicated that trochanteric B
MD (decrease of 1.0 SD, adjusted OR 4.6, 95% Cl 2.0-9.5, p < 0.0001) a
nd femoral neck BMD (increase of 1.0 SD, adjusted OR 3.0, 95% Cl 1.6-5
.9, p = 0.0003) were independently associated with trochanteric fractu
re. Fall characteristics, body habitus, gender, and age were not assoc
iated with hip fracture type. We conclude that a relatively low trocha
nteric BMD or a high femoral neck BMD was associated with a trochanter
ic hip fracture and that site-specific trochanteric BMD determinations
should be measured when assessing risk of trochanteric hip fractures
in the elderly.