Cl. Benhamou et al., FRACTAL ORGANIZATION OF TRABECULAR BONE IMAGES ON CALCANEUS RADIOGRAPHS, Journal of bone and mineral research, 9(12), 1994, pp. 1909-1918
Bone density is not the unique factor conditioning bone strength. Trab
ecular bone microarchitecture also plays an important role. We have de
veloped a fractal evaluation of trabecular bone microarchitecture on c
alcaneus radiographs. Fractal models may provide a single numeric eval
uation (the fractal dimension) of such complex structures. Our evaluat
ion results from an analysis of images with a varying range of gray le
vels, without binarization of the image. It is based on the fractional
brownian motion model, or more precisely on the analysis of its incre
ment, the fractional gaussian noise (FGN). The use of this model may b
e considered validated if two conditions are fulfilled: the gaussian r
epartition and the self-similarity of our data. The gaussian repartiti
on of intermediate lines of these images was tested on a sample of 32,
800 lines from 82 images. Following a chi-square goodness-of-fit test,
it was checked in 86% of these lines for alpha = 0.01. The self-simil
arity was tested on 20 images by two estimators, the variance method o
f Pentland and the spectrum method of Fourier. Self-similarity is defi
ned by lined-up points in a log-log plot of the FGN spectrum or of the
variance as a function of the lag. We found two self-similarity areas
between scales of analysis ranging from 105 to 420 mu m, then above 9
00 mu m, where linear regression produced high mean correlation coeffi
cients (r greater than or equal to 0.97). Following this validation, w
e studied the reproducibility of this new technique. Intra- and intero
bserver reproducibility, influence of transferring the region of inter
est, and long-term reproducibility were assessed and given CV of 0.61
+/- 0.15, 0.68 +/- 0.47, 0.53 +/- 0.16, and 2.07 +/- 0.84%, respective
ly. These data have allowed us to validate the use of this fractal mod
el by checking the fractal organization of our radiographic images ana
lyzed by the model. The good reproducibility of successive x-rays in t
he same subject allows us to undertake population studies and to envis
age longitudinal series.