Six randomized, double-blind, two-period crossover studies, conducted
under similar protocols, compared the efficacy of two analgesic combin
ations containing caffeine with an acetaminophen 1000 mg control and w
ith a placebo in outpatients with episodic tension-type headaches. In
four studies, comprising 1900 patients, the caffeine-containing analge
sic consisted of a combination of 500 mg acetaminophen, 500 mg aspirin
, and 130 mg caffeine (APAP/ASA/CAF). In two studies, comprising 911 p
atients, the caffeine-containing analgesic consisted of a combination
of 1000 mg acetaminophen and 130 mg caffeine (APAP/CAF). Patients self
-medicated for moderate or severe headache pain, and with a self-ratin
g record they rated their pain and its relief hourly for 4 hours. In a
ll six studies, the caffeine-containing analgesics were significantly
superior bath to placebo and to 1000 mg acetaminophen, and acetaminoph
en was significantly superior to placebo. The significant analgesic ad
juvant effect of caffeine was independent of patients' usual caffeine
use or their caffeine consumption in the 4 hours before medication. Fo
r each treatment, the pooled analgesic responses for the four studies
of APAP/ASA/CAF were virtually superimposable on the responses in the
two APAP/CAF studies. The combinations produced more stomach discomfor
t, nervousness, and dizziness than acetaminophen or placebo.