R. Munton et T. Marsden, DUALISM OR DIVERSITY IN FAMILY FARMING - PATTERNS OF OCCUPANCY CHANGEIN BRITISH AGRICULTURE, Geoforum, 22(1), 1991, pp. 105-117
The dualist thesis of structural change in advanced capitalist agricul
ture, postulating the disappearance of the middle-range family farm, i
s examined. In the case of the U.K., aggregate statistical evidence in
support of this tendency is not forthcoming whereas in the United Sta
tes recent research has downplayed the trend. It is suggested that the
thesis is too structuralist, paying inadequate attention to the range
of responses to be found among farming households and generally direc
ting attention to patterns rather than processes of adjustment. In ord
er to analyse the latter, a series of detailed farm interviews, provid
ing social and economic profiles of farm business change between 1970
and 1985, was conducted in three contrasting agricultural areas of sou
thern England. The survey data revealed important local differences se
t within broadly similar trends though with a high level of unpredicta
bility regarding individual household strategies. Areas requiring furt
her detailed analysis are outlined.