We analyze risk-sensitive, incentive-compatible deposit insurance in t
he presence of private information and moral hazard. Without deposit-l
inked subsidies it is impossible to implement risk-sensitive, incentiv
e-compatible deposit insurance pricing in a competitive, deregulated e
nvironment, except when the deposit insurer is the least risk averse a
gent in the economy. We establish this formally in the context of an i
nsurance scheme in which privately informed depository institutions ar
e offered deposit insurance premia contingent on reported capital; the
result holds for alternative sorting instruments as well. This sugges
ts a contradiction between deregulation and fairly priced, risk-sensit
ive deposit insurance.