Data from a 1972 three-state survey are used to compare city, suburban
, town, and rural dwellers in terms of five urbanism characteristics:
(1) anonymity, (2) tolerance, (3) community social bonds, (4) alienati
on, and (5) deviant behavior. Suburbanites displayed less urbanism tha
n city dwellers, but they did not differ much from other noncity peopl
e in this regard. In fact, residents of the various types of settlemen
t do not fall on a neat continuum of urbanism from country to town to
suburb to city. The dominant pattern is simply a city-noncity differen
tiation, although there are a few anomalies. These results suggest tha
t urban theories have limited usefulness for understanding urbanism am
ong suburbanites, but they also reveal so little evidence of suburban
distinctiveness that it may not require a unique explanation beyond th
at needed to account for simple urban-nonurban differences.