In this paper we present linkage results from the analysis of 18 Utah
breast cancer kindreds, for three 17q markers. Four kindreds had LOD s
cores greater than 1.0 for at least one of the marker loci. One of the
se kindreds has a LOD score of 6.07 with D17S579, and we believe it to
be the most informative 17q family reported to date. Among the kindre
ds which appear unlinked to 17q were an early-onset breast cancer fami
ly, a large breast-ovarian family, and a kindred with mixed age at ons
et. Analysis of individual recombinants in the linked families localiz
es the BRCA1 gene between THRA1 and D17S579 (Mfd188). A comparison of
the Cancer and Steroid Hormone Study (CASH) model and a model which as
sumes a rare dominant susceptibility locus with low penetrance and no
phenocopies stresses the difficulties in assessing linkage if the assu
mptions of the CASH model in terms of age at onset of breast cancer ar
e not appropriate for the BRCA1 locus. A hypothetical breast cancer pe
digree is used to calculate gene carrier probabilities under the CASH
model, thereby illustrating some of our concerns regarding the use of
this model to detect and exclude 17q linkage in breast cancer families
.