W. Maenhaut et al., ANALYSIS OF SIZE-FRACTIONATED COAL COMBUSTION AEROSOLS BY PIXE AND OTHER ANALYTICAL TECHNIQUES, Nuclear instruments & methods in physics research. Section B, Beam interactions with materials and atoms, 75(1-4), 1993, pp. 266-272
Particle-induced X-ray emission (PIXE) analysis, instrumental neutron
activation analysis (INAA) and inductively coupled plasma mass spectro
metry (ICP-MS) were used to study the chemical composition of size-fra
ctionated in-stack fly-ash particles emitted during coal combustion. T
he samples were collected before the electrostatic precipitator at a g
as temperature of 120-degrees-C during the combustion of Venezuelan co
al in a 81 MW capacity circulating fluidized bed boiler. The sampling
device consisted of a Berner low pressure impactor, which was operated
with a cyclone precutter. The Nuclepore polycarbonate foils, which we
re used as collection surfaces in the low pressure impactor, were anal
yzed by the three techniques, and the results of common elements were
critically compared. The PIXE results were systematically lower than t
he INAA data, and the percentage difference appeared to be stage-depen
dent, but virtually independent upon the element. The discrepancies ar
e most likely due to bounce-off effects, particle reentrainment and ot
her sampling artifacts, which may make that a fraction of the aerosol
particles is deposited on the impaction foils outside the section anal
yzed by PIXE. However, by resorting to a ''mixed internal standard'' a
pproach, accurate PIXE data are obtained. Also in the comparison betwe
en the ICP-MS and the INAA data significant discrepancies were observe
d. These are most likely due to incomplete dissolution of the particul
ate material, and in particular of the alumino-silicate fly-ash matrix
, during the acid digestion sample preparation step for ICP-MS. It is
suggested that a comparison between ICP-MS data of acid digested sampl
es and INAA can advantageously be used to provide speciation informati
on on the various elements. Selected examples of size distributions ar
e presented and briefly discussed.