The positive association between growing up in a nonintact family and
the risk of a first premarital birth has been interpreted by researche
rs as consistent with three hypotheses: (1) a childhood socialization
hypothesis - that women who grow up in a mother-only family during ear
ly childhood are socialized in ways that result in a high risk of a pr
emarital birth; (2) a social control hypothesis - that the supervision
of adolescents is more difficult in single-parent families than in tw
o-parent families; and (3) an instability and change hypothesis - that
a premarital birth is a response to the stresses accompanying changes
in a woman's family situation. Although these hypotheses imply distin
ct behavioral mechanisms, adjudicating between them has proven difficu
lt, in part because researchers have relied on static measures of fami
ly structure. We use data from the National Survey of Families and Hou
seholds and continuous-time hazard models to investigate the effects o
n premarital births of dynamic family measures that reflect a woman's
family situation between birth and age 19. Our findings are consistent
with the instability and change hypothesis, but provide little suppor
t for the socialization hypothesis and the social control hypothesis.