In a previous paper, J. Membrane Sci., 60 (1991) 185-193, large separa
tion factors (as high as 600) were reported for methanol/hydrogen mixt
ures. These reported results are not accurate. Repetition of the exper
iments gave separation factors between 1.5 and 4 depending on the tota
l pressure at 473 K. The same experimental apparatus and alumina membr
anes were used in this study. These results indicate that capillary co
ndensation in the membrane pores is not the primary separation mechani
sm as had been previously reported.