The cosmic Mach number M is the ratio of the bulk flow of the galaxy v
elocity field on some scale R to the small-scale velocity dispersion w
ithin regions of scale R. Because M is the ratio of two velocities, it
is independent of the amplitude of the power spectrum and of the bias
parameter in linear theory. We develop a robust method to derive this
statistic from existing peculiar velocity data sets. For the infrared
Tully-Fisher distances of spirals in the Local Supercluster of Aarons
on and collaborators. we find M = 1.03 and a characteristic distance f
rom the Local Group of 1464 km s-1; for the elliptical galaxy sample o
f Faber et al., we find M = 0.57 with a characteristic distance of 257
2 km s-1, and for the R-band Tully-Fisher sample of Willick in the Pis
ces-Perseus region, we find M = 1.05 with a characteristic distance of
5265 km s-1. The bulk flow of the Willick sample is 717 km s-1, appre
ciably larger than in the other two data sets. We compare these result
s with Monte Carlo simulations of the observational realizations drawn
from numerical simulations of the universe based on various scenarios
, including the standard cold dark matter (CDM) scenario. The galaxies
of the simulations mimic the distribution of the real galaxies in bot
h position and environment. We find the effect of velocity bias on the
derived Mach number to be small. Only 5% of the CDM simulations have
M as large as or larger than that observed for the Aaronson et al. sam
ple. We test three further models: the standard hot dark matter model,
the primordial isocurvature baryon model, and the tilted CDM model, i
n which the logarithmic index of the primordial fluctuation spectrum i
s n = 0.7 rather than the simplest inflationary prediction of unity. A
ll three models are able to match the observed Mach number for the Aar
onson et al. sample in more than 15% of realizations. The Mach number
test is a powerful discriminator between models for the origin of cosm
ological structure, and it rejects the standard CDM scenario at the 94
% confidence level.