Decreased production of butyric acid by colonic carbohydrate fermentat
ion may predispose to colonic carcinogenesis, with the implicit assump
tion that the decrease in faecal butyrate found predates the developme
nt of the tumour. The influence of the genetic predisposition to colon
ic tumours and the presence of colonic polyps on in vitro fermentation
of carbohydrates was examined. Stool samples from 11 normal controls
and 20 patients with familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP) were incubat
ed anaerobically with a range of carbohydrates. Fermentation patterns
were similar for glucose and raffinose. These sugars produced differen
t short chain fatty acid (SCFA) patterns from the two polysaccharides,
starch and arabinogalactan, which differed one from the other. The FA
P gene carriers with polyps produced less butyrate than normal control
s (p<0.005) and gene carriers without polyps (p<0.05). There were corr
esponding decreases in the molar ratios of butyrate. Gene carriers wit
hout polyps produced less absolute amounts of acetate than normal cont
rols (p<0.05) and slightly less total SCFAs (p<0.05) but were otherwis
e not significantly different. The decreased production of butyrate no
ted by other workers may be secondary to the tumours rather than a con
tributory cause.