Re. Farrell et al., EFFECTS OF CHEMICAL SPECIATION IN GROWTH MEDIA ON THE TOXICITY OF MERCURY(II), Applied and environmental microbiology, 59(5), 1993, pp. 1507-1514
The toxicity of metals, including mercury, is expressed differently in
different media, and the addition of soluble organics to the growth m
edium can have a significant impact on bioassay results. Although the
effect of medium composition on metal toxicity is generally attributed
to its effect on metal speciation (i.e., the chemical form in which t
he metal occurs), the importance of individual metal-ligand species re
mains largely unclear. Here, we report the results of a study that inv
estigated, both experimentally and from a modeling perspective, the ef
fects of complex soluble organic supplements on the acute toxicity (i.
e., 50% inhibitory concentration [IC50]) of mercury to a Pseudomonas f
luorescens isolate in chemically well-defined synthetic growth media (
M-IIX). The media consisted of a basal inorganic salts medium suppleme
nted with glycerol (0.1%, vol/vol) and a variety of common protein hyd
rolysates (0. 1%, vol/vol), i.e., Difco beef extract (X = B), Casamino
Acids (X = C), peptone (X = P), soytone (X = S), tryptone (X = T), an
d yeast extract (X = Y). These were analyzed to obtain cation, anion,
and amino acid profiles and the results were used to compute the aqueo
us speciation of Hg(II) in the media. Respirometric bioassays were per
formed and IC50s were calculated. Medium components varied significant
ly in their effects on the acute toxicity of Hg(II) to the P. fluoresc
ens isolate. IC50s ranged from 1.48 to 14.54 mug of Hg ml-2, and the a
cute toxicity of Hg(II) in the different media decreased in the order
M-IIC much-greater-than M-IIP > M-IIB much-greater-than M-IIT > M-IIS
>>> M-IIY. The calculated IC50s were related to the aqueous speciation
of Hg(II), and a significant negative correlation (r = -0.904) (P = 0
.05) between the IC50 and the mole fraction of Hg(II) bound in Hg-chlo
ride complexes was observed. This was particularly noteworthy because
the only source of chloride in the M-IIX media was the organic supplem
ents. There also was a significant positive correlation (r = 0.831) (P
= 0.05) between the IC50 and the mole fraction of free Ca2+ plus Mg2 in the media, suggesting that these ions have a moderating effect on
the toxicity of Hg(II). Overall, differences in the mole fractions of
Hg-chloride complexes (primarily HgCl+, HgCl20 and HgClOH0) and free C
a2+ plus Mg2+ accounted for about 96% of the variation in the acute to
xicity of mercury (i.e., R2 = 0.955) (P = 0.01).