Fj. Morrison et al., NATURE-NURTURE IN THE CLASSROOM - ENTRANCE AGE, SCHOOL READINESS, ANDLEARNING IN CHILDREN, Developmental psychology, 33(2), 1997, pp. 254-262
The impact of entrance age on reading and mathematics achievement in 1
st grade was examined. Methodological problems with past research were
identified, including small size of achievement differences, failure
to take background variables into account and confusion of achievement
levels with degree of learning. Using a pre-post design, growth of re
ading and mathematics was examined in younger 1st graders, older 1st g
raders, and older kindergarteners. Comparisons of background informati
on on these groups with children who were either held out prior to or
retained an extra year in kindergarten, produced minimal background di
fferences. Results revealed that younger ist graders made as much prog
ress over the school year as did older 1st graders and made far more p
rogress than older kindergarteners. Overall, findings demonstrated tha
t, in itself, entrance age was not a good predictor of learning or aca
demic risk.