Fa. Vaneeuwijk et A. Elgersma, INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMATION IN AN ANALYSIS OF GENOTYPE BYENVIRONMENT INTERACTION FOR SEED YIELD IN PERENNIAL RYEGRASS, Heredity, 70, 1993, pp. 447-457
Seed yield in perennial ryegrass was analysed for cultivar by environm
ent interaction. Nine cultivars were evaluated in 12 trials at two loc
ations over a 3-year period. Earlier attempts to describe the signific
ant cultivar by environment interaction using a regression on the envi
ronmental mean or relationships with year, soil type, harvest method,
or crop age, were unsuccessful. In this paper, therefore, meteorologic
al data were introduced as explanatory variables. Three types of analy
sis were used. First, residuals from the cultivar by environment two-w
ay table corrected for main effects were regressed on the explanatory
variables for each cultivar separately. Secondly, the explanatory vari
ables were used as concomitant variables for the environmental factor
in a two-way analysis of variance of genotypes by environments. Finall
y, the matrix of residuals from additivity was subjected to a singular
value decomposition, after which environmental scores were related to
values of the explanatory variables using regression and a recently d
eveloped method to calculate confidence intervals for scores. All meth
ods led to comparable conclusions about the importance of different va
riables in the interaction. Of equal importance were minimum temperatu
re in the period before ear emergence, temperature sum in the period f
rom the beginning of anthesis until peak anthesis, and mean and maximu
m temperature in the period from the end of anthesis until harvest. Th
e major component of interaction was identified as a contrast between
early and late cultivars. A minor component was due to cultivars that
performed relatively well in the worst environment and relatively badl
y in the best environment. The usefulness of so-called AMMI models is
discussed and compared with that of the more traditional regression on
the environmental mean model.